question about sleeping with hair in a bun

[Stub]

So last night I put my hair into a bun on the top of my head to try sleeping in it. Held with 2 claw clips. First of all, it felt like it was pulling when I laid down so I had to adjust the claws several times until they felt OK. They'd be fine when I was standing up but feel like they were pulling when I laid down. I slept well with my hair like that, didn't notice the clips at all in the night. But when I woke up and took the bun down this morning, my scalp felt REALLY weird for several minutes. I am guessing I had the bun too tight and it pulled all night. So my question is, how do you do this sleeping with your hair in a bun thing? If the bun is tight enough to stay bunned through tossing and turning (which I do a lot of) then how do I make it not also pull on my scalp? I normally sleep with my hair in a loose braid but it's getting long enough to strangle me now yet not quite long enough to stay over the pillow if I toss it upward when I first go to sleep, so I am looking for a new way to wear it at night. A sleep cap is not an option, because I can't stand things on my head while sleeping!

[PixieP]

For most it'll take the scalp some time to get used to having an updo for that long, especially if it's very high on your head and you aren't used to high buns. I've sleep with a high smooshed cinnabun/bantu knot held with a satin scrunchie for 3 years or so now, and for the first couple of months my scalp would be tingly and over-sensitive in the morning when taking it down. But by now my scalp is used to having a high bun for hours at a time.

I have tried securing it with other things, like spin pins and claw clips, and the satin scrunchie wins for me every time. When I make the bun I wrap the ends around the base like you do with an LWB and other center-held buns, I can actually make this bun with greasy hair and it holds up for a while without anything securing it. The scrunchie helps keep it in place and I also like to think that it helps protect the hair somewhat, the scrunchie covers almost the entire bun so it doesn't rub around on the sheets.

[Stub]

So it won't damage the hair roots or make it fall out to be a little tight all night and feel tingly in the morning? That's great news! It's what I worried about when it felt funny this morning. Thank you PixieP!
p.s. - I like the satin scrunchie idea!

[PixieP]

Well mine hasn't fallen out yet, so I think you're safe XD it's just your hair roots are not used to being pulled that way. It's kinda the same as when in winter you haven't shaved your legs in a few weeks, and then wear stockings, and when you take them off in the evening the skin feels weird because the leg hair has been pulled upwards all day :P

[vampyyri]

I usually either use a claw clip or spin pins... Spin pins are the most comfortable if you do a cinnabun on top and secure it with a few pins, it also makes for some really nice bun waves the next morning!

[Cg]

I make a braided topknot nautilus with short fat stick. Fat sticks keep the bun tight enough without pulling and stay in despite tossing and turning. It does take a few tries to figure out the right tension and position. You'll get there in no time.

[Upside Down]

If I wear a braid during the day, I sleep in a high lwb held by anything on the shirt side I have handy.
It feels good to change the direction hai is pulling on the roots...

[sumidha]

What about a pony tail with a scrunchie on the top of your head? I do my sleep buns super loose so they don't pull on my scalp or anything, but I'm not sure if BSL is long enough for a loose bun to stay put all night yet.

[spidermom]

I'm a top of head ponytail kind of sleeper. Sometimes I braid the ponytail for added containment.

[enting]

I'm with PixieP, it probably feels weird from the hairs being positioned in a way that they're not used to. As long as you're not bunning too tightly, there shouldn't be a concern of making hair fall out.

When I bun my hair for sleep I do a somewhat loose cinnabun topknot with either spin pins or several hairpins. When I use hairpins, at least one pin usually manages to work its way out by morning, but it does keep my hair contained all night anyway. I know what you mean about it feeling fine when standing but then it pulls when lying down. When that happens, I redo the pin that is pulling while lying down, or I move it to a different spot on my head, or sometimes I just get rid of that pin altogether and rely on the other pins to keep everything together. A scrunchie sounds like a really comfortable idea if it will hold. It definitely sounds worth trying out.

Would you be interested in a satin bun cover? It wouldn't cover your whole head, but it might help keep the bun together and help protect it from tossing and turning. I toss and turn a lot and at some point discovered that if I'm not careful, my topknot rubs a lot against my headboard!